Might sound like a weird question, so here's a bit of context:

The story I'm writing is quite fantasy-driven (i.e. characters can seemingly "create" elements like thunder and water out of thin air). However, despite these fantasy elements, a lot of realistic moments occur which are often based in human unpredictability, so it's not like characters don't fear anything because they possess special powers or whatnot. Parts can easily turn into a killing/slaughter scenario a la "A Song of Ice and Fire", or even "Attack on Titan".

In a certain scene, an entire village was put up in flames. Amidst the confusion created by this, a man saves another fellow man from a house that is completely alit in flames. Upon his rescue, the half-burnt man asks his hero to save his daughter who's still in the house, to which he replies with the question: «How old is your daughter?». The other man is baffled by this response, not understanding where he's coming from, to which he backs up with «If your daughter is around 4 years old, there's nothing I can do».

My explanation is that this character is not risking his life if he knows the person-to-save would most likely die even after being rescued when other (possibly more important) lives are concurrently in danger. So my question is this: If a house is on fire, are young children more prone to faint since they have a more underdeveloped body system than adults, or, due to their size, can they stay safe from smoke and large fires by sticking themselves into corners until their rescue arrives?

  • 1
    Hi, and welcome to Writers. This is a research question, or "what to write," which is not on-topic for us.
    – Lauren Ipsum
    Apr 15 '16 at 1:38
  • Ah, I'm really sorry about that! I should've paid more attention to how the best questions were asked before I could start with this. I was just trying to check if fantasy scenarios could still incorporate details such as this one.
    – Keyaku
    Apr 15 '16 at 1:41
  • @Keyaku: No worries; people learn here by trial and error :)
    – Standback
    Apr 15 '16 at 6:30
  • I'm voting to close this question as off-topic because it is a research question.
    – Standback
    Apr 15 '16 at 6:31
  • I think this may be on-topic at Health.SE, I'll try sending it there.
    – Neil Fein
    Apr 20 '16 at 4:09

There's a reason why, in a house fire, the phrase to remember is "Get down low and go, go, go"

The most common ailment of someone in a house fire is from smoke inhalation. As smoke rises, the closer you are to the floor, the less smoke you will breathe in (until the entire room is filled with smoke in which case you're dead anyway).

From this perspective, as long as the child stays away from the flame, they are actually more likely to last longer than an adult, purely because they are smaller, lower to the ground and not breathing in as much smoke.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy