For hypothyroidism where TSH is elevated (> 10 μU per mL) but T3 and T4 are in the normal range, what is the effect of prescribing hormone replacement (e.g. Levothyroxine)?

My understanding is that TSH stimulates T4 and conversely T3, but since those are already in the normal range what are the effects of prescribing Levothyroxine, which in my mind is just more TSH.

1 Answer 1


The lab parameters you describe (slightly elevated TSH, normal T3/T4) in isolation are an indication of latent hypothyroidism.

In general, this is interpreted as a thyroid gland not functioning optimally anymore; and thus more TSH is needed to stimulate the production of physiological T3/T4 levels. The current viewpoint is that this compensation mechanism is only temporary and at some point, the thyroid will likely fail to produce enough T3/T4 even with more TSH stimulation and hypothyroidism ensues.

(Side note: This is why usually always T3/T4 (levothyroxine) are supplemented and not TSH, as the high TSH is an indication that the thyroid gland is not sufficient in producing T3/T4).

In itself, a moderately raised TSH value (>4 <10 mU/L) on its own is not a health condition requiring treatment, but the risk does exist that the patient will go on to develop overt hypothyroidism with its potential for associated cardiovascular sequelae (8, 9, e1, e2). The treating physician must therefore decide whether to leave the patient untreated, or to treat the patient even though there is no clear indication for doing so and the risk is of triggering iatrogenic hyperthyroidism.


The linked review (albeit a bit dated) nicely discusses some points for shared-decision making whether to start T3/T4 supplementation or not.

Elevated TSH levels above >10mU/l but still normal T3/T4 levels are less common, the article goes to mention here that

[i]n some studies, subclinical hypothyroidism has been shown to be an independent risk factor for the development and exacerbation of heart failure and coronary heart disease (9, e1, e2). However, a clear relationship was demonstrated only in the patient group =70 years of age with subclinical hypothyroidism and a TSH value >10 mU/L (29, 30, e1, e34– e36), so it is only for this patient group that a treatment recommendation can be made.

  • Thank you for this excellent answer! The linked article is also very much appreciated, it is extremely well written.
    – totsubo
    Dec 17, 2022 at 22:16

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.