0

In this article it has been mentioned twice that Africans are more prone to liver damage by Isoniazid:

Other risk factors are preexisting liver disease (hepatitis B or C), concurrent use of rifampin or pyrazinamide, and possibly alcoholism, black race and genetic factors.

Acute liver failure from isoniazid appears to be more common in women than men, and in African Americans more than Caucasians.

Can somebody please explain me the real science behind it?

1
  • 2
    I don't know about this case, but it's quite possible there isn't any "real science" behind it; this sort of thing is usually just a reported observation: you have a group of people who were given the drug, you look at the percentage of people who suffered liver damage afterwards, you look at what demographics set those people apart. Since it's just a correlational observation, the causes are not clear from a study like this, but they need not be directly related to race but rather other factors that covary with race like socioeconomic status.
    – Bryan Krause
    Commented May 12, 2022 at 14:25

1 Answer 1

2

Firstly the causes of liver failure in those taking the drug (1):

The cause of liver injury due to Isoniazid is believed to be accumulation of a toxic intermediate of its metabolism. Rates of injury may be somewhat higher in patients with a slow acetylation status, marked by genotypic variants in N-acetylation, or with abnormalities in CYP 2E1, the second major enzymatic pathway of its metabolism. [..] Despite the lack of prominent features of hypersensitivity, rapid recurrence of injury can occur with rechallenge, suggesting that the injury is immune-mediated, at least in part.

- The CYP 2E1 referred to is thought to be responsible for clearing the body of drugs and toxins:

Human CYP2E1 catalyses the metabolism of low-molecular-weight xenobiotics, including drugs [..], solvents [..] and procarcinogens [..].

There are many known versions of this, the prevalence of some is known to vary by race (3):

Both rs3813867:C and rs2031920:T alleles are common in Asian populations but rare in Caucasians and Africans (Zavras et al., 2002).

But no detailed research of the link between specific CYP2E1 variants present and liver toxicity to Isoniazid in African subjects.

- Genotypic variants in N-acetylation (2).

This refers to a group of alleles that are thought to be involved in the production of enzymes or other substances which render environmental substances (typically plant or bacterial toxins and the like) harmless, and reduce their carcinogenicity. There are in excess of 14 known variants of this, and the number of variants in African-heritage peoples is typically larger than that found in Caucasian subjects. The implication being that the greater diversity in this part of the genome confers a disadvantage in breaking-down Isoniazid, as a narrow set of variants, which are found more frequently in Caucasians is more effective in rendering it non-noxious.

  • Conclusion.

There are indicators that more than one variation in the phenotypes which are more common in Africans may well result in lower tolerance to the toxic effects of this drug or its metabolites, however the research has yet to definitively predict which variants will be at risk especially as it seems to be potentially more than one factor at play including an immune-mediated response.

(1) LiverTox: Clinical and Research Information on Drug-Induced Liver Injury National Library of Medicine.

(2) Differences in N-acetylation genotypes between Caucasians and BlackSouth Africans: implications for cancer prevention Researchgate.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.