I just read a German article comparing influenza with COVID-19. There is a table with Mortality displacement (rates? cases?) and laboratory-confirmed cases of influenza.

I'm super confused by this table. I think I know what laborartory-confirmed death cases are:

  • A person dies and the symptoms indicated influenza
  • A sample (e.g. spit) is taken
  • The virus can be proven to be there
  • Other reasons for the death can be ruled out

I thought that Mortality displacement would be an estimation of the unknown cases: For many dead people there is not laboratory test.

But the two things that don't quite fit:

  1. The Mortality displacement is sometimes 0.
  2. The Mortality displacement is sometimes lower than the laboratory-confirmed cases, e.g. 2009/10.
  3. The Mortality displacement is sometimes vastly higher than the laboratory confirmed cases: 2008/09 the Mortality displacement was 18,800 and the laboratory-confirmed cases were 10.

Can somebody explain mortality displacement in a simple way?

  • Are you asking about mortality displacement or about excess mortality? The linked article talks about excess mortality (Übersterblichkeit) only. Apr 3 '20 at 20:21
  • I was asking about "Übersterblichkeit". I thought that was the correct translation as the wikipedia articles link to each other. Isn't that the case? Apr 3 '20 at 20:37
  • To solve the confusion in the body of the question, I recommend reading an RKI influenza season report, e.g. influenza.rki.de/Saisonberichte/2018.pdf. They explicitly state that numbers of deaths with lab-confirmed influenza are not a valid base for extrapolating "influenza deaths", for a variety of reasons. Moreover, they explain that influenza surveillance was reorganized around 2011. You may have noticed that the number of deaths with confirmed influenza infection jumps up by a factor of ≈10 around there. Tagesschau has a somewhat hidden hint that they composed the table. Apr 3 '20 at 21:13

It's the number of deaths an event has caused to be shifted in time. So,there's a very high rate of deaths right now from covid-19 in Italy amongst the older population. Those deaths are occurring now instead of in the future so those deaths are displaced from the future to now. As a result the number of deaths in the older population after the pandemic finishes will be less since they were displaced to a different time.

  • I'm not entirely sure (since I'm not a native English speaker), but there may be an issue with the translation OP uses: while this explanation of mortality displacement makes sense to me, the linked article exclusively discusses excess mortality (so regardless of whether the excess deaths are followed by lower-than-expected death rates). Apr 3 '20 at 20:19
  • I am only explaining mortality displacement which is what is being asked I don't read German. People are being odd if I'm being marked down for answering the question correctly when the OP has mistranslated the article! Apr 3 '20 at 21:00
  • Graham, I'm not marking you down. I was only puzzled since I perceived a discrepancy between the headline question, the body of the question and what is discussed in the linked article. Different topic: can you confirm my understanding that excess mortality in contrast is about having more deaths than seasonally expected - regardless of whether this is followed by a lower-than-expected death rate? Or, formulated in different manner: does mortality displacement imply the lower death rate being short to maybe medium term, i.e. just after the cause of the excess mortality is gone? Apr 3 '20 at 21:08
  • 1
    Someone has marked down my answer. I didn't say it was you. Apr 3 '20 at 21:10

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.