Has having allergy induced asthma which can also be aggravated by intense exercise been shown to get worse after having tonsils removed in adult males? A common treatment for repeatedly getting Angina Tonsillitis in a short space of time is to have the tonsils removed. Has this been shown to increase the risk of catching Bronchitis in adult asthmatics?

Angina Tonsillitis severely affects an asthmatics ability to breath easily causing airways to remain aggravated restricted often resulting in the patient having to take increased medication for extended periods of time to regain normal quality of breathing. Has Bronchitis which is often prevented by normal functioning tonsils been shown to be worse for asthmatics than tonsillitis and are they more susceptible to catching it after having their tonsils removed than before and more so than non-asthmatics?

The following source deals with and indicates there is an increased risk of COPD following tonsil and or adenoid removal but does not deal at all with the case which I am interested in, which is if the the risk increase of incidence in asthmatics is increased after a tonsillectomy as compared to subjects who already frequently get Angina Tonsillitis.

A more detailed review of the study described here breaks down the results further. Again this does not address my question as the dataset does not sufficiently cover adult males who already suffer from asthma and are prone to getting Tonsillitis already. I want to know if the risk of getting a COPD disease is increased after a Tonsillectomy for subjects who are already more prone than normal to getting Tonsillitis and if the increased risk of a COPD disease has been shown to have a greater negative impact on subjects measured quality of life than chronic Tonsillitis.

Even better will be any concrete results on the measure of how asthma is affected after having both diseases.

  • 2
    Welcome to MedicalSciences.SE! For a number of reasons outlined in this meta post, we can not, and will not, give personal medical advice. If you have a question regarding your personal health, you should see a doctor. For further information on how this site is supposed to work, what is on-topic or not, you can take the tour, visit the How to Ask page and Medical Sciences Meta. I have voted to close this question and this post explains question closure. Commented Nov 19, 2018 at 18:48
  • 2
    As you seem to know that personal medical advice is strictly off-topic: please edit out all personalised info and add some prior research on of your own, which is also required here. A generalised question might work, the current approach chosen does not. Commented Nov 19, 2018 at 18:50
  • 1
    Aesir, please heed LangLang's request. When you've completed the edits and the question is a general question useful to others and it demonstrates some prior research, I will reopen it.
    – Carey Gregory
    Commented Nov 19, 2018 at 18:56
  • 1
    I re-worded the question. I am not sure how I can show prior research without being able to provide specific information. As my prior research has involved talking to medical professionals and as is often the case with conditions like asthma highly individual. I don't think however that warrants the question as not suitable. As an asthma sufferer and not an educated medical professional there is not enough public information available on this topic, hence asking here.
    – Aesir
    Commented Nov 19, 2018 at 19:09
  • 2
    Asking multiple questions at once is frowned upon, and your title openly asked for advice, so I made some additional edits and reopened the question. You're always free to ask your other questions separately.
    – Carey Gregory
    Commented Nov 19, 2018 at 19:47


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.