Can getting enough high quality sleep cancel out the harmful effects of overtime work or not getting enough vacation?

Recently, articles said that taking less than 3 weeks of vacation increases the risk of death by 37%! The study even found that a healthy diet and exercise doesn't even help but didn't seem to talk about whether sleep would cancel out the harmful effects. Subjects could report how much sleep they got and the study could take it into account. Here's one:

If high quality sleep can really cancel out the harmful effects, someone could work around 14 hours five days a week without harmful effects. I left 10 hours because sleep efficiency can only go so high, and we need time for breaks, exercise, healthy eating, etc.

If sleep is the main factor, then those with insomnia need to find ways to sleep well if they want to benefit from the vacations. For those who need to catch up on sleep, it could mean half day vacations so that it's effectively a sleep vacation. Someone might start work in the afternoon so that it's possible to sleep in for a few extra days.

Correction The study actually said that the subjects slept less when taking shorter vacations.

  • Why do you think sleep might be a deciding factor? Most people don't have insomnia and sleep just as well when they're working as they do on vacation, and those people were presumably represented equally in the study population. – Carey Gregory Sep 8 at 0:50
  • I assume that people are likelier to cut back on sleep when they work longer hours. Lack of sleep is common in college students. It couldn't be caused by poor diet or lack of exercise from the lack of time because they were taken care by of the study. – Han-Lin Sep 13 at 5:56
  • Actually, the study said that they slept less when taking shorter vacations. Sorry for my misreading. It didn't say whether it was because they were used to ignoring their feelings of sleepiness, higher stress makes a person feel less sleepy or feel like they need less sleep, or whether they slept more outside of vacations when they were longer. I still feel that it's easier to tell whether it was the long hours itself that was unhealthy if they adjusted for sleep since sleep is considered as important for health as diet and exercise, if not more. – Han-Lin Sep 13 at 6:06

Your Answer


By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.