5

Aside from the obvious (electrolyte loss), why could standard demineralized water be harmful?

If you buy the usual demineralized water at the hardware store (for car batteries, steam irons, …) sometimes there's a warning from the manufacturer like “Not recommended for drinking” … but why?

Is it just a generic warning to remove liability, if the manufacturer accidentally does something wrong (contamination of the source water, lack of hygiene) or are there some harmful byproducts inherently generated by the usual industrial process of demineralization?

  • Average tap water contains relatively low amount of minerals. Most minerals come from food. If you eat regularly and drink demineralized water, no "mineral loss" should happen. – Jan Aug 17 '18 at 8:57
  • 1
    It's not being manufactured to food standards. – Graham Chiu Aug 17 '18 at 23:16
  • @santimirandarp you'd be dead before that happened – Graham Chiu Aug 18 '18 at 3:44
  • @santimirandarp because. – Graham Chiu Aug 18 '18 at 3:47
  • 1
    Please check biology.stackexchange.com/questions/2250/… – user11906 Aug 18 '18 at 4:12
1

As pointed out by the more reputable answer at the similar question at Biology.SE (backed with sources of information and hence more highly voted), what would happen if you drank only distilled water is nothing perceptible. The only place where concentrations of distilled water would ever be high enough to conceivably matter is in the tissues of the mouth and throat, and even there, the effect would be temporary.

Compare drinking 8 glasses of either distilled or tap water every day. With tap water, you're looking at less than 200 ppm of Mg, Na, K, and Ca combined. That's less than 400mg of total mineral content per day. Given that the combined RDA of all of those minerals is on the order of 7g for an adult male, this is not nothing, but it's certainly small. Your dietary intake of these minerals probably varies by more than this daily, and your intestines, kidneys, sweat glands and mineral storage organs (like your bones and muscles) are constantly maintaining the mineral blood levels within a very narrow range, despite handling a throughput of several pounds of water and food daily. They might have to work slightly harder to manage this range if you drank nothing but distilled water, but in a healthy adult, normal intakes already vary by more than this amount without major problems. For example, the average American consumes more than 3.4 grams of sodium daily, while a low-sodium diet is on the order of 2g. Low-sodium diets have been widely studied in the medical literature, and are considered safe.

As for pH, the lowered pH is caused by increased carbon-dioxide absorption to form carbonic acid. Just as carbon dioxide is more soluble in distilled water, it is less soluble in stomach acid, and may be burped out. Would you die of acidosis from drinking seltzer water all the time? If that were the case, I'm sure there would be big health warnings about drinking soda, while it seems relatively benign. Furthermore, your body produces and excretes (through the lungs) around 1kg of CO2 daily, dwarfing any extra CO2 you might get by drinking distilled water. If the small amounts of CO2 found in distilled water were dangerous, jogging would be invariably fatal.

If you were to drink nothing but distilled water, and eat no food, you probably would die of hyponatremia within a few weeks. But you would also die of hyponatremia if you were to drink nothing but tap water, though perhaps slightly more slowly.

| improve this answer | |
0

The problem is the obvious electrolyte loss , especially if you mean distilled water.It may not be a problem with a diet containing enough electrolytes.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.